Court Weighing School COVID Mitigations
Demonstrators outside the Illinois State Board of Education building protest a statewide indoor mask mandate in all public and nonpublic schools Aug. 18, 2021, in Springfield. (Capitol News Illinois file photo by Peter Hancock
Lawsuit seeks to block mask mandates, exclusion rules.
By Peter Hancock
Capitol News Illinois
phancock@capitolnewsillinois.com
SPRINGFIELD – A Sangamon County judge is considering a motion to block Illinois schools from requiring people to wear face masks in classes and excluding students and staff from school buildings if they’ve had close contact with someone who tested positive for COVID-19.
Circuit Judge Raylene Grischow heard oral arguments last week in a class action lawsuit against 145 school districts that was filed last year by Greenville attorney Thomas DeVore, who has unsuccessfully challenged the state’s COVID-19 mitigation measures in several other lawsuits.
In September, DeVore filed a motion for a temporary restraining order to permit students to continue in-person learning in school.
Attorney General Kwame Raoul’s office is defending the districts and the Illinois Education Association, along with the Illinois Federation of Teachers, and has entered the case as intervenors on behalf of the teachers they represent.
The cases were originally filed individually in several Illinois counties but were later consolidated into Sangamon County Circuit Court.
At issue is whether school districts are violating state law by implementing orders from Gov. JB Pritzker and guidelines from the Illinois Department of Public Health and Illinois State Board of Education to impose certain mitigation measures in order to hold in-person instruction.
Those measures include requirements that: All students, staff, and visitors wear face coverings in school buildings; students and staff be excluded from buildings if they test positive for COVID-19 or have been in close contact with someone else who has; and school personnel be vaccinated or submit to weekly testing.
In the suit, DeVore argues exclusions amount to a kind of “quarantine” and, under the Department of Public Health Act, schools cannot exclude students for public health concerns without their parents’ consent or a quarantine order from a public health department.
He also argues schools have no legal authority to require vaccinations or the wearing of masks unless a public health department has issued a quarantine order.
“The plaintiffs have a right to insist the students not be excluded from school and denied their right to an in-person education, except as provided by law,” the lawsuit states.
“Quite simply, the defendants are infringing upon the lawful right of the students, and of their parents or guardians, to be free to choose for themselves whether mask wearing as a treatment or type of modified quarantine, for the purpose of limiting the spread of an infectious disease, absent a court order, is appropriate,” the lawsuit states
DeVore has been the attorney in numerous lawsuits representing businesses and individuals challenging Pritzker’s executive orders during the pandemic. In one, he represented state Sen. Darren Bailey, R-Xenia, a Republican candidate for governor.
Judge Grischow, however, threw out that case in December 2020, finding that the governor has the authority to issue multiple, successive disaster proclamations stemming from one ongoing disaster.
In a motion to dismiss the case, the Illinois Education Association argued that masking and exclusions are not “quarantines” and, therefore, are not preempted by the Public Health Act. It also argues the joint guidance issued by IDPH and ISBE gives school districts lawful authority to impose mask and exclusion mandates.
In a separate filing, the Illinois Federation of Teachers argued the public health interest involved in preventing the spread of COVID-19 outweighs any individual right of the students and parents who are challenging the mandates.
“Those parents, students, teachers, and staff who are not before the court have a compelling interest in the enforcement of mitigation measures that reflect the best judgments of policymakers facing rapidly changing circumstances,” attorneys for the IFT wrote.
The case against the school districts has generated significant public interest. During a hearing on January 5, Grischow noted in a journal entry, “the court and the court’s receptionist began receiving emails from outside sources setting forth their position on the issues being argued in the case.”
“The court did not review the emails and turned them over to the U.S. Marshals office to review for security reasons,” Grischow wrote. “The emails will not be kept or reviewed by the court. Any opinion rendered in these matters will be based on the law and not personal opinions.”
Capitol News Illinois is a nonprofit, nonpartisan news service covering state government and distributed to more than 400 newspapers statewide. It is funded primarily by the Illinois Press Foundation and the Robert R. McCormick Foundation.
Illinois News
Classifieds
Monee Police Blotter: April 11 – 28
Spread the loveOn April 11, at approximately 4:25 p.m., officers responded to a theft complaint at Thorntons and met with a University Park woman who explained to officers she had lost her credit card and soon discovered it had been used on three separate occasions at Thorntons to purchase gas. Investigation took over and determined…
KRRC Donates $800 to Manteno Legion
Spread the loveRecently, the Kankakee River Running Club (KRRC) donated $800 Springfest 5K Run/Walk profits to the Manteno American Legion. Springfest was held on April 13 in Manteno. The Running Club also donated a Monical’s Family Pleaser pizza and Certificate of Appreciation to the Manteno Police Department for their yearly support and route assistance during…
Rep. Haas Calls Out Sneaky Tactics in Senate Bill 2412
Spread the loveFollowing the passage of House Floor Amendment 2 to Senate Bill 2412 through the House, State Rep. Jackie Haas released the following statement. “I am deeply disappointed and concerned by the passage of Senate Bill 2412, as well the unnecessarily brisk process that brought it to the House floor,” said Rep. Haas. “This…
Attention Seniors: Community Nutrition Network/Senior Services Association Announce Newest Location
Spread the loveCommunity Nutrition Network and Senior Services Association is thrilled to announce the grand opening of its newest location, New Hope Christian Community Church, 4700 W. Court Street, Monee, which is scheduled for June 7, from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. Community Nutrition Network and Senior Services Association invites the community to celebrate this…
River Valley Metro Ridership Milestone
Spread the loveOn Tuesday, April 30, River Valley Metro Mass Transit surpassed 14 million rides since it began serving the community in 1999. “This number reflects the need in our community for safe and reliable public transportation,” said Managing Director Siron Sims. “Whether the need is to get to work, school, appointments, shopping, or social…
Will County Holding Annual Textiles, Small Home Goods Collection May 6-10
Spread the loveWill County Executive Jennifer Bertino-Tarrant invites residents to the annual Textile and Small Home Goods Collection Event at the Will County Office Building, 302 North Chicago Street, Monday, May 6 through Friday, May 10. A wide range of items will be collected for reuse and recycling during the week, including coats, shirts, pants,…
Crete Library News
Spread the loveThursday, May 9 Anime Club, from 3 – 4:30 p.m., grades sixth/12th: Join us for a screening of “Mobile Suit Gundam Wing.” Snacks and refreshments will be provided. Register. Trivia Night at Evil Horse, 1338 Main Street, from 7 – 9 p.m.: Compete on your own or bring a group of friends. Prizes…
PHS Track and Field Senior Night April 25
Spread the lovePeotone High School honored its track and field athletes on Thursday, April 25, at Track and Field Senior Night. Congratulations and good luck to the following athletes! Franco Perez is the son of Janette and Jose Perez and a first-year member of the team. One of Franco’s favorite team memories was riding the…
PHS Honors Athletes at Soccer Senior Night
Spread the loveOn Thursday, April 25, Peotone High School honored its seniors at Soccer Senior Night. Congratulations and good luck to the following ladies! Zoie Balaskas, daughter of Nicole and Dino Balaskas, is a four-year member of the soccer team. One of Zoie’s favorite team memories occurred during a regional game when rain washed off…
Peotone Library News
Spread the loveSummer Reading Program registration begins Monday, June 3 for all ages. Interested in being a sponsor – stop by or give us a call. Interested in the Homebound Delivery Program? Contact the Adult Services Department for more information and guidelines. Register for events on the website calendar or call the library at 708-258-3436.…
Mother’s Day Basket Bingo May 11
Spread the loveMark your calendar for “Mother’s Day Basket Bingo,” the bi-annual basket bingo fundraiser for Flight Club Survivor. This fun event will be held on Saturday, May 11, with doors opening at 5 p.m. and bingo at 6 p.m., at 209 W. Dixie Highway in Grant Park. Tickets are $20 per person for the…
Healing and Investment Key to Growth in Our Communities, State
Spread the love“Put yourself in their shoes. Have a heart.” As a member of the Illinois Senate’s budget committee on Health and Human Services, I work with my fellow legislators to understand the needs in our communities and try to match resources to meet those needs. These are never easy decisions because homelessness and housing…
Beecher Community Library News
Spread the loveCall the library at 708-946-9090 for programs that require registration. May 2 – May 30: Visit the library for their gallery of tiny art from more than 100 Beecher patrons! Available any time. Outdoor Used Book Sale: A number of used books are for sale, for $1 each, on the front veranda. There…
DeLuca Backs Reforms to Make Health Care More Affordable, Expand Access
Spread the loveLooking to drive down health care costs and expand access for families, State Rep. Anthony DeLuca recently backed an insurance reform plan that prioritizes patients by cracking down on large rate increases, banning “step therapy,” and stopping “junk insurance” plans that provide no real coverage. “These are needed reforms that recognize the challenges…
House Passes Rep. Haas’ Bill Addressing Childcare Shortage
Spread the loveHouse Bill 4059, filed by State Rep, Jackie Haas, recently passed the House with a unanimous vote of 104-0. “The passage of House Bill 4059 is the first step in addressing the critical shortage of licensed daycare providers in the State of Illinois,” said Rep. Haas. “This bill ensures the Department of Children…