UPDATED: Optional all-gender bathrooms bill will head to governor
By PETER HANCOCK
Capitol News Illinois
phancock@capitolnewsillinois.com
SPRINGFIELD – The Illinois General Assembly has passed a bill that would allow businesses and public institutions to provide multi-occupant all-gender bathrooms if they choose to do so.
House Bill 1286 would change current state law, under which single-occupancy bathrooms are automatically designated for all genders, but multi-occupancy bathrooms must be designated as male or female. It needs only a signature from Gov. JB Pritzker to become law.
While the measure had already passed the House on March 23, the amended version heads back to the chamber for consideration before it can be sent to Gov. JB Pritzker.
Justin Sia, a Chicago attorney, testified in committee this week that he came up with the idea for the bill while in law school at Loyola University. He described it as “a pro-family, pro-business and pro-safety bill that permits, not mandates, public and private entities to install gender inclusive, multi-stall restrooms.”
Sia said he’d heard from transgender and gender nonbinary individuals who were “insulted and even attacked in male or female restrooms simply for who they are or for how they look.” But he said he also heard from caregivers for adults of a different gender and others who would benefit from gender-inclusive restrooms.
“We also learned about parents and guardians with young children of a different gender who must decide whether to leave their children unattended in public restrooms, or to enter a restroom that doesn’t match their gender,” he said.
In its original form, HB 1286 would have required that each toilet stall in an all-gender bathroom be separated by dividers and have a functioning lock mechanism on the door. Urinals, if present, also would have to be separated by partitions.
But the Senate amended the bill to require that all-gender bathrooms have “floor-to-ceiling” toilet stalls with workable locks and that urinals not be allowed.
Sen. Celina Villanueva, D-Chicago, is pictured on the floor of the Illinois Senate Thursday during debate over her bill that would allow optional all-gender bathrooms at businesses and public institutions in the state. (Capitol News Illinois photo by Andrew Adams)
“We took into consideration the concerns of several members who voiced that concern in terms of people who walk into a restroom and might be offended by a urinal,” bill sponsor Sen. Celina Villanueva, D-Chicago, said during committee. “So what we were trying to do is to make sure that we address the concerns. And again, a urinal is just as good as a toilet.”
“Are they going to be offended if I leave the toilet seat up?” asked Sen. Neil Anderson, R-Andalusia, in that committee.
“I mean, I might be offended,” Villanueva replied.
“I’ve raised four boys and it’s going to be messy,” said Sen. Jil Tracy, R-Quincy, prompting laughter from many in the room, including Villanueva. “I see it as a sanitary issue.”
Sen. Jil Tracy, R-Quincy, is pictured on the Senate floor. (Capitol News Illinois photo by Andrew Adams)
But when the bill reached the Senate floor on Thursday, the tone of the debate became harsher and more bitter. There, Anderson said the bill would lead to violence.
He spoke about taking his 10-year-old daughter out in public and how he handles a situation when she needs to use a restroom. He tells her to go inside and check to see if anyone else is in the room. If there is, he says he waits for her outside.
“If somebody goes in there and it’s a woman, fine,” he said. “Under this, I can’t see with the floor-to-ceiling things. She won’t be able to see who’s in there. I won’t be able to see who’s in there. I’m telling you right now, if a guy walks in there, I’m gonna beat the living piss out of him.”
Sen. Neil Anderson, R-Andalusia, is pictured on the floor of the Illinois Senate Thursday. (Capitol News Illinois photo by Andrew Adams)
That prompted shouts of support from other Republicans. But later in the debate, Sen. Mike Simmons, D-Chicago, said the comment should be stricken from the record, “because I wouldn’t want a single person in this state to read that record and think that anybody here would come after them if they would do something so mundane as to use the bathroom, a simple call of nature.”
Sen. Chapin Rose, R-Mahomet, also suggested passage of the bill would lead to violence. He argued that most sexual assaults in bars occur in bathrooms. Rose also argued that, beyond the issue of sexual assaults, the measure isn’t needed.
“I’ve talked to my wife about this,” he said. “Why on earth would any lady want a dude in their bathroom?”
Senate Majority Leader Kimberly Lightford, D-Westchester, and Senate President Don Harmon, D-Oak Park, are pictured on the Senate floor. (Capitol News Illinois photo by Andrew Adams)
Meanwhile, Sen. Cristina Castro, D-Elgin, accused Republicans of using “dog-whistle” language – coded or suggestive language to draw support from a particular group – and Senate Majority Leader Kimberly Lightford, D-Westchester, said the opponents “have a problem with the LGBTQ community.”
The measure passed the Senate on a vote of 35-20, sending it back to the House which approved it on a vote of 63-41. It will next be sent to the governor for consideration.
The debate in the House lacked much of the vitriol that characterized the Senate discussion, although House Republicans raised many of the same concerns as their Senate colleagues.
Rep. Dan Ugaste, R-Geneva, is pictured on the floor of the Illinois House. (Capitol News Illinois photo by Jerry Nowicki)
“I hate to say it because it doesn’t speak well of my gender,” said Rep. Dan Ugaste, R-Geneva. “But since the dawn of time, young men and men in general have done awful and horrendous things to young women and women, and allowing them to follow them into a washroom when we know that it’s led to bad consequences in other areas of the country already – this is not a good idea.”
But Rep. Jaime Andrade, D-Chicago, said he would actually feel safer sending his 13-year-old daughter into a restroom that has floor-to-ceiling stalls.
Rep. Jaime Andrade, D-Chicago, is pictured on the floor of the Illinois House. (Capitol News Illinois photo by Jerry Nowicki)
“You know, instead of someone reaching over someone trying to talk to her, even a woman or a man, who knows?” he said. “Even my son when he goes into a washroom.”
Bill sponsor Rep. Katie Stuart, D-Edwardsville, reiterated in floor debate that businesses and schools can determine how they want to designate their restrooms.
“They can stick with traditional men’s and women’s, no one has to change anything,” she said. “Or they can go with solely gender neutral.”
Rep. Katie Stuart, D-Edwardsville, who sponsored the optional all-gender restroom bill, is pictured on the floor of the Illinois House Friday. (Capitol News Illinois photo by Jerry Nowicki)
She also noted that the measure allows all-gender bathrooms to count toward restroom ratio requirements under existing state law.
“So I’ve actually had a couple of superintendents in rural areas that are looking to redesign their bathroom configuration and actually want more of those … single-stall restrooms,” she said. “And they appreciated that this bill fixes that issue with how those count.”
Editor’s note: This story has been updated to reflect the bill’s House passage. Jerry Nowicki contributed to the update.
Capitol News Illinois is a nonprofit, nonpartisan news service covering state government. It is distributed to hundreds of print and broadcast outlets statewide. It is funded primarily by the Illinois Press Foundation and the Robert R. McCormick Foundation, along with major contributions from the Illinois Broadcasters Foundation and Southern Illinois Editorial Association.
Classifieds
Music, Ugly Sweaters, Hot Chocolate, Sinterklaas, Oh My!
Spread the loveThe Kankakee County Historical Society will host their annual ugly sweater and hot chocolate party on Friday, December 15, from 3 to 8 p.m.! Enjoy an evening of holiday cheer right in the middle of the Kankakee County Museum’s 45th Annual Gallery of Trees, 801 S. Eighth Avenue! This year’s ugly sweater party…
Crete Library News
Spread the loveThursday, December 14 Preschool Pals, from 1 – 2 p.m., ages four/five: During this independent storytime experience, children enjoy spending time with other pre-schoolers, while listening to stories, learning songs and finger plays, and playing games. Register. Anime Club, from 3 – 4:30 p.m., grades sixth/12th: Join us for a screening of “Trigun:…
Riverside Named One of Illinois,’America’s Healthiest Employers
Spread the loveRiverside ranked 20th in healthiest 100 workplaces in America. Health and wellness are vital to fostering a productive and resilient workforce, something Riverside Healthcare takes seriously. For its dedication to promoting employee health, Riverside was named one of the Healthiest 100 Workplaces in America, ranking 20th in the nation. Additionally, Riverside earned first…
Seggebruch Family Marks Anniversary with Donation
Spread the loveBy Karen Haave A prominent Will County family has marked the 170th anniversary of its ancestors’ arrival in America, with donations to two local historical societies. Fourth and fifth generation descendants of the Seggebruch family gathered for a presentation of personal artifacts to the Monee Historical Society and to the Crete Area Historical…
Beecher Thinking About That Levy
Spread the loveBy Jeff Vorva The Village of Beecher Board Members agreed to take a little more time before deciding what they will do about the 2024 tax levy. Finance and Administration Committee Chairman Todd Kraus said at the November 27 meeting they could make a decision that night or table it, but it needs…
Illinois Office of Tourism Names Cranky Mike’s Popcorn to Illinois Made Program4
Spread the loveGovernor J.B. Pritzker, alongside the Illinois Department of Commerce and Economic Opportunity (DCEO), elected officials, and industry leaders, proudly unveiled the latest inductees into the Illinois Made program, including Cranky Mike’s Popcorn in Momence. This year marks a significant milestone, as 48 exceptional small businesses, often referred to as ‘Makers,’ have been welcomed…
Peotone Travel Center Now Open for Business
Spread the loveBy Andrea Arens The Peotone Travel Center cleared the Fire Marshall on Friday, December 1, and immediately “soft-opened” for business. Village President Peter March was the first customer. “We are excited to have the Peotone Travel Center open for business today, December 1. It has been a long journey but seeing the final…
Extensive Rural Fire Kills 4 Horses
Spread the loveAt approximately 3:37 p.m. on Sunday, November 26, the Beecher Fire Protection District, along with automatic aid, responded to a structural fire at 1624 E. Eagle Lake Road. Due to reports of animals still inside the building, the alarm was escalated to the full still alarm level prior to arrival. The first suppression…
New State-of-the-Art Election Equipment Demonstration Planned
Spread the loveWill County Clerk Lauren Staley Ferry is inviting the public to a demonstration of new state-of-the-art election equipment that will be used to cast and count ballots in next year’s Primary and Presidential Elections. County Clerk Staley Ferry and her team will conduct demonstrations of the new ballot counters, ADA-compliant ballot-marking devices, and…
Gotion Rezoning Unanimously Approved
Spread the loveBy Stephen Nelson The recent Planning Commission meeting was a stark contrast to the November 21 special meeting of the Manteno Planning Commission that lasted more than four-and-a-half hours and, at times, became quite contentious, when opponents of the project, which would bring an electric vehicle battery manufacturing plant owned by Chinese interests…
Kankakee County Museum Presents Gallery of Trees and More
Spread the loveThe Kankakee County Museum, 801 S. Eighth Avenue, Kankakee, invites area residents to the annual Gallery of Trees. Celebrating 45 years of this beloved local tradition, this year the Museum is filled with more than 35 trees decorated by area non-profit organizations, based on favorite themes from the past 45 years. Traditionally, more…
Child Network Offering CASA Training
Spread the loveEvery year, more than three million children nationally are reported abused or neglected. Despite the states’ attempts to help, many of these kids become trapped in the court and child welfare maze and can spend their childhood moving from one temporary shelter to another. This is where you can step in by becoming…